The doubts library · Doubt itself
Where to ask your doubts without being judged
“Where can I ask my doubts without being judged, or having my post taken down?”
This is really common, and you're not doing anything wrong by asking. Many people have had a question removed online, or been told off for asking it at the mosque. That says more about the place than about you. There are people who are glad to hear exactly this kind of question.
Asking is part of the religion
The Quran tells people to ask when they don't know:
So ask the people of the message if you do not know.
(Quran 16:43)
The angel Jibril taught the Companions their religion by asking the Prophet, peace be upon him, questions in front of them (Sahih al-Bukhari 50, graded sahih). And Aisha praised the women of the Ansar, because their shyness did not stop them from learning their religion, even when the question was a private one (Sahih Muslim 332, graded sahih).
Where to take which kind of question
- To talk it through. A mentor listens first and doesn't rush you. Lighthouse Mentoring offers private, one-to-one conversations.
- A question of knowledge. SeekersGuidance Answers is a large library of scholars' answers, and you can send in a question of your own. Yaqeen Institute publishes long-form research on the hard questions. The Islamic Library lists more places to send a question.
- Your own situation. A ruling about your prayers, a vow or your marriage needs a qualified scholar or your local imam, asked directly.
- Near you. A local imam, a revert circle or a youth group.
More people you can reach are on Talk to someone.
How to ask so you get a good answer
- Say what it is. The question in one or two sentences, and where you came across it.
- Say it's a doubt you want help with. Most teachers answer more gently when they know you're struggling, not arguing.
- Ask one question at a time. A long list gets short answers.
- If an answer feels harsh, ask someone else. One unkind reply is not the voice of Islam.
Signs of a good place to ask
They listen before they answer. They're honest when something is hard, or when scholars differ. They don't mock or shame you. They never ask for money to answer your doubts, don't push you into private messages with someone you don't know, and don't rush you into any decision.
Is this a question or a loop? If the same worry keeps coming back however many answers you read, it may be waswasa, and more answers won't settle it. Read about waswasa first.
If this is hitting you hard
If being judged before has made you afraid to ask again, start small: one question, to one person. A mentor is a good first step, because their whole job is to listen. And if you feel close to leaving, the page if you're thinking of leaving is written for exactly where you are.
What to do this week
One question, one person. That's the whole plan.
- Write your question downOne or two sentences, plus where you came across it.
- Pick where to take itA mentor to talk it through, or a scholar for a question of knowledge.
- Send it this weekThen give yourself permission to wait for the answer.
Go deeper
Questions people ask
Is it okay to ask a scholar about my doubts?
Yes. Asking is how this religion has always been taught. A good scholar or teacher will be glad you came to them rather than carrying the question alone.
Why was my question removed online?
Some forums remove posts about doubts to keep arguments down. It isn't a judgement on you or on your question. A person you can talk to one to one is usually a better place for it anyway.
Can I ask about my own situation on this site?
This site doesn't answer personal questions or give rulings. For your own situation, ask a qualified scholar or your local imam. To talk a doubt through, a mentor is a good place to start.
What if the answer I get feels harsh?
It's okay to ask someone else. One unkind reply doesn't speak for Islam. Look for a teacher who listens first and explains calmly.
Free to read, no account needed. Every page here is open to you without signing up. If you'd like a gentle note now and then, you can leave your email for our newsletter. It's optional, and you can unsubscribe any time. Like most websites, we use analytics to see which pages help people.